Ithy - Ithy

Comprehensive Ranking of Marriott Properties in San Francisco (February 2025)

This ranking is based on a synthesis of user recommendations from Reddit and FlyerTalk, focusing on properties that offer breakfast for Platinum members. Estimated prices are for February 2025, and all properties listed provide breakfast benefits for Platinum members, either through lounge access or restaurant options. The analysis considers location, service, amenities, and overall user consensus.

1. St. Regis San Francisco

Breakfast: Platinum members enjoy breakfast in the restaurant as part of their welcome gift.
Service and Amenities: The St. Regis is consistently praised for its exceptional service, modern style, and high-quality food and beverage offerings. It is frequently cited as one of the best hotels in San Francisco.
Location: Well-located, though some users find the surrounding area less vibrant compared to other neighborhoods.
Estimated Price (February 2025): $600 - $1,200 per night.
User Consensus: Overwhelmingly positive reviews highlight the luxurious experience and top-tier service.
Analysis: The St. Regis stands out for its superior service and quality, making it a top choice for those seeking a luxury experience. The included breakfast for Platinum members adds significant value.

2. The Ritz-Carlton, San Francisco

Breakfast: While not explicitly stated as a free benefit, Platinum members often receive a credit towards breakfast in the restaurant, which is highly rated for quality and presentation.
Service and Amenities: The Ritz-Carlton is renowned for its exceptional service, luxurious rooms, and personalized attention.
Location: Located in Nob Hill, offering a quieter setting with stunning views, though slightly uphill from main attractions.
Estimated Price (February 2025): $500 - $900 per night.
User Consensus: Consistently praised for its service and breakfast, though some users note the breakfast credit may not fully cover the cost of menu items.
Analysis: The Ritz-Carlton offers a high-end experience with exceptional service, making it a strong contender for luxury travelers. The breakfast benefit, while not fully complimentary, is still a significant perk.

3. Westin St. Francis, San Francisco

Breakfast: Platinum members receive lounge access, which includes breakfast, and can also have breakfast in the restaurant.
Service and Amenities: The hotel is praised for its great staff, comfortable rooms, and excellent breakfast buffet.
Location: Historically rich location in Union Square, providing a central and convenient base for exploring the city.
Estimated Price (February 2025): $300 - $600 per night.
User Consensus: Users appreciate the historical charm, excellent staff, and the quality of the breakfast buffet.
Analysis: The Westin St. Francis offers a blend of historical charm and modern comfort, with a well-regarded breakfast offering for Platinum members.

4. JW Marriott San Francisco Union Square

Breakfast: Platinum members receive lounge access, which includes breakfast. If the lounge is closed, they can have breakfast in the restaurant.
Service and Amenities: The hotel is noted for its comfortable rooms and modern amenities, though some find the style to be a standard Marriott design.
Location: Centrally located in Union Square, which is convenient but described as "boring" by some users.
Estimated Price (February 2025): $350 - $700 per night.
User Consensus: Generally well-regarded for its location and service, though it lacks the unique charm of some other properties.
Analysis: The JW Marriott is a solid choice for its central location and reliable service, with a good breakfast offering for Platinum members.

5. Palace Hotel, San Francisco

Breakfast: Platinum members receive lounge access, which includes breakfast. If the lounge is closed, they can have breakfast in the restaurant.
Service and Amenities: Users appreciate the hotel's historical significance and charm.
Location: Located in a historically rich area, offering a unique experience.
Estimated Price (February 2025): $300 - $600 per night.
User Consensus: The Palace Hotel is praised for its historical significance and good value for the quality offered.
Analysis: The Palace Hotel provides a unique experience with its historical setting and a solid breakfast benefit for Platinum members.

6. San Francisco Marriott Marquis

Breakfast: Platinum members receive lounge access, which includes breakfast. If the lounge is closed, they can have breakfast in the restaurant.
Service and Amenities: While not specifically highlighted in the sources, Marriott Marquis hotels generally offer good amenities and services, though they may lack the unique charm of other properties.
Location: Located near Union Square, which is convenient but can be busy.
Estimated Price (February 2025): $320 - $700 per night.
User Consensus: Generally well-regarded for its location and breakfast offerings, though some users find it impersonal.
Analysis: The Marriott Marquis is a convenient option with a good breakfast benefit, suitable for those who prioritize location and amenities over unique charm.

7. San Francisco Marriott Union Square

Breakfast: Platinum members have lounge access, which includes breakfast. If the lounge is closed, they can have breakfast in the restaurant.
Service and Amenities: Users appreciate the lounge and the views, but describe the hotel as "very beige" and lacking in historical charm.
Location: Located in Union Square, which is convenient but described as "boring" by some users.
Estimated Price (February 2025): $300 - $600 per night.
User Consensus: While convenient, the hotel is often described as lacking in character compared to other options.
Analysis: The San Francisco Marriott Union Square is a practical choice for its location and breakfast benefit, but it may not appeal to those seeking a more unique experience.

8. Marriott Courtyard Fisherman's Wharf

Breakfast: This property provides a generous breakfast benefit for Platinum members, including an actual entree from the restaurant.
Service and Amenities: Users praise the higher ratings, no destination fee, and the $20 Food & Beverage credit. The breakfast is highlighted as one of the best Bonvoy breakfasts in SF.
Location: Located in Fisherman's Wharf, which is family-friendly but may not be as central as Union Square.
Estimated Price (February 2025): $250 - $500 per night.
User Consensus: The Courtyard at Fisherman's Wharf is highly regarded for its generous breakfast benefit and family-friendly location.
Analysis: This Courtyard property stands out for its exceptional breakfast offering and value, making it a great option for families and those seeking a more relaxed atmosphere.

9. W Hotel San Francisco

Breakfast: Platinum members can enjoy breakfast in the restaurant, but users note that the breakfast choices for elites are limited.
Service and Amenities: Users appreciate the great beds but find the breakfast options limited for elites.
Location: The location is described as closer to the "grunge" of SF, which may not be optimal for families.
Estimated Price (February 2025): $300 - $600 per night.
User Consensus: Popular with younger travelers, but the breakfast benefit is considered less appealing due to limited options.
Analysis: The W Hotel offers a trendy experience, but the limited breakfast options for elites may be a drawback for some travelers.

Summary Ranking

St. Regis San Francisco - Top-tier luxury, exceptional service, and high-quality breakfast.
The Ritz-Carlton, San Francisco - Renowned for luxury and service, with a highly-rated breakfast experience.
Westin St. Francis, San Francisco - Historical charm, great staff, and an excellent breakfast buffet.
JW Marriott San Francisco Union Square - Central location, comfortable rooms, and reliable service with a good breakfast.
Palace Hotel, San Francisco - Historically significant with good value and a solid breakfast benefit.
San Francisco Marriott Marquis - Convenient location and amenities, with a good breakfast for Platinum members.
Marriott Courtyard Fisherman's Wharf - Generous breakfast benefit, family-friendly location, and good value.
San Francisco Marriott Union Square - Convenient location, but lacks unique charm compared to other properties.
W Hotel San Francisco - Trendy, but with limited breakfast options for elites.

This ranking reflects the consensus from user feedback, emphasizing the quality of service, amenities, and the inclusion of breakfast for Platinum members. Prices are estimates for February 2025 and may vary based on availability and specific dates.