Discovering the Best Key Lime Pie in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania

A Guide to Finding That Perfect Tart and Sweet Slice

Highlights for Key Lime Pie Lovers in Harrisburg

The Pennsylvania Bakery: Frequently mentioned as a top spot for Key Lime Pie with both whipped cream and white chocolate mousse options.
Dodge City Steakhouse: Known for its Key Lime Pie, often appearing on "best of" lists for the area.
Urban Churn: Offers a unique Key Lime Pie Crumble ice cream for a frozen twist on the classic dessert.

Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, offers a variety of delightful dessert options, and for those with a craving for the zesty and refreshing taste of Key Lime Pie, there are several notable establishments to explore. From traditional bakeries to steakhouses and even ice cream shops, you can find this classic treat in various forms throughout the city and surrounding areas.

Top Destinations for Key Lime Pie

Bakeries and Sweet Shops

Bakeries are often the first place dessert enthusiasts look for a classic Key Lime Pie. Harrisburg is home to several highly-regarded bakeries that feature this popular dessert.

The Pennsylvania Bakery

The Pennsylvania Bakery is consistently highlighted as a premier location for Key Lime Pie in Harrisburg. They offer variations such as the Key Lime Whipped Cream Pie, available in both 6-inch and 8-inch sizes, and a Key Lime White Chocolate Mousse Pie. Their pies are described as baked with a topping of whipped cream and fresh lime wedges. This bakery is a family-owned establishment known for a wide array of baked goods, including cakes, pies, breads, and pastries.

Located at 1713 Market St, Camp Hill, PA, The Pennsylvania Bakery is a popular spot for many dessert needs in the Harrisburg area.

A peek at some offerings from a local bakery.

JUST BAKED CAKES & PIES

Another strong contender for the best pie in Harrisburg is JUST BAKED CAKES & PIES. Located in Midtown Harrisburg, they are known for "desserts that remind you of Grandma’s." While their specific Key Lime Pie offering isn't always detailed, they are highly rated for their pies in general and share space with the Midtown Scholar Bookstore, offering a unique combination of treats and literature.

Anna Rose Bakery & Coffee Shop

While often praised for their cakes and pastries, Anna Rose Bakery & Coffee Shop is another highly-rated bakery in Harrisburg that may offer Key Lime Pie or other lime-flavored treats depending on their rotating selection. They are recognized for delicious pastries and desserts.

Other Notable Bakeries

Other bakeries in the Harrisburg area mentioned for their pies include Oak Grove Farms and Alvaro Bread and Pastry Shoppe. While not exclusively focused on Key Lime Pie, their inclusion on lists of best pie places suggests they are worth exploring for various pie options.

Restaurants Featuring Key Lime Pie

Beyond dedicated bakeries, several restaurants in Harrisburg also feature Key Lime Pie on their dessert menus, offering a sweet conclusion to a meal.

Dodge City Steakhouse

Dodge City Steakhouse is frequently listed among the best places to get Key Lime Pie in the Harrisburg area. This suggests it's a popular and well-regarded option for enjoying this dessert in a restaurant setting.

An exterior view of Dodge City Steakhouse.

Harvest Seasonal Grill - Harrisburg

Harvest Seasonal Grill in Harrisburg is another restaurant mentioned as a place to find Key Lime Pie. Known for its seasonal menu, their dessert offerings may vary, but its appearance on "best of" lists indicates a positive reception for their version of the pie.

Lancaster Brewing Company (Harrisburg)

Surprisingly, Lancaster Brewing Company's Harrisburg location also offers Key Lime Pie on their menu, specifically listed as "KEY LIME PIE FOR 2." This presents an unexpected but potentially delicious option for those looking for the dessert.

Unique Key Lime Pie Variations

For those looking for a different take on Key Lime Pie, some establishments offer creative variations.

Urban Churn

Urban Churn, a popular ice cream shop, features a "Key Lime Pie Crumble" ice cream. This offers the tangy flavor of key lime pie combined with crunchy crust bits in a frozen format, perfect for a hot day or a different kind of dessert experience.

Key Lime Pie Crumble ice cream from Urban Churn.

Hershey's® Ice Cream

Hershey's® Ice Cream offers a "Key Lime Pie" flavor described as a rich lime mousse ice cream swirled with lime and whipped cream ribbons and graham cracker chunks. This is another excellent option for enjoying the flavors of Key Lime Pie in ice cream form.

Delivery Options for Key Lime Pie

If you prefer to enjoy Key Lime Pie in the comfort of your own home, delivery services are available from several locations in Harrisburg.

Services like Uber Eats and DoorDash list restaurants and bakeries that offer Key Lime Pie for delivery in the Harrisburg area. Some options that may be available for delivery include The Pennsylvania Bakery and potentially others depending on your specific location.

Factors to Consider When Choosing

When deciding where to get your Key Lime Pie in Harrisburg, several factors might influence your choice:

Desired Style

Do you prefer a traditional baked pie with a graham cracker crust and meringue or whipped cream topping, or are you open to variations like ice cream or a mousse pie?

Location and Convenience

Consider how close the establishment is to you and whether they offer dine-in, takeout, or delivery options.

Reviews and Recommendations

Websites like Yelp and Tripadvisor provide reviews from other customers, which can offer insights into the quality and taste of the Key Lime Pie at different locations.

Other Offerings

If you're getting dessert as part of a larger outing, consider the other menu items or the overall atmosphere of the establishment.

Summary of Key Lime Pie Options

Here is a table summarizing some of the places in Harrisburg where you might find Key Lime Pie:

Establishment	Type of Offering	Notes
The Pennsylvania Bakery	Baked Pie (Whipped Cream, White Chocolate Mousse)	Available in different sizes, highly recommended.
Dodge City Steakhouse	Baked Pie	Frequently listed as a top spot.
Urban Churn	Key Lime Pie Crumble Ice Cream	A frozen variation.
Hershey's® Ice Cream	Key Lime Pie Ice Cream	Lime mousse ice cream with mix-ins.
JUST BAKED CAKES & PIES	Baked Pie (Likely)	Known for various pies, located with a bookstore.
Harvest Seasonal Grill - Harrisburg	Baked Pie (Seasonal)	Restaurant with seasonal menu.
Lancaster Brewing Company (Harrisburg)	Baked Pie	Offered as a dessert item.

This table provides a quick overview of some of the places to find Key Lime Pie or a variation in Harrisburg.

Frequently Asked Questions About Key Lime Pie in Harrisburg

Which bakery is considered the best for Key Lime Pie?

Based on multiple sources, The Pennsylvania Bakery is frequently cited as one of the best places to get traditional Key Lime Pie in Harrisburg due to positive reviews and mentions on "best of" lists.

Can I get Key Lime Pie delivered in Harrisburg?

Yes, several places that offer Key Lime Pie in Harrisburg are available for delivery through services like Uber Eats and DoorDash. Availability may depend on your specific address.

Are there non-traditional Key Lime Pie options available?

Yes, for those interested in something different, Urban Churn offers a Key Lime Pie Crumble ice cream, and Hershey's® Ice Cream has a Key Lime Pie flavored ice cream.

Are there restaurants that serve Key Lime Pie?

Yes, restaurants like Dodge City Steakhouse, Harvest Seasonal Grill, and even Lancaster Brewing Company (Harrisburg) have been noted for including Key Lime Pie on their dessert menus.