Filament Dryer Face-Off: Sunlu vs. eSUN vs. Sovol vs. Creality – Which Reigns Supreme?

Highlights: Key Takeaways

• Noise Levels Vary Significantly: From the generally quiet Sunlu S1 to potentially noisy fan-driven models like the Sovol SH01/SH02 and Creality Space Pi Plus, sound output is a major differentiator.
• Efficiency & Features Drive Price: Higher-priced models like the Sovol SH02 and Creality Space Pi Plus often boast faster heating (PTC elements), higher temperature capabilities, and better controls, justifying their cost for serious users.
• Airtightness Isn't Universal: While some models offer improved seals (Sovol SH02, potentially Creality), many basic dryers are not designed for long-term, unpowered moisture protection. True airtightness often requires dedicated dry boxes or modifications.

Why Choosing the Right Filament Dryer Matters

3D printing filament, especially materials like Nylon, PETG, TPU, and even PLA to some extent, is hygroscopic – meaning it readily absorbs moisture from the air. Wet filament leads to a host of printing problems: stringing, oozing, popping sounds during extrusion, brittle prints, poor layer adhesion, and rough surface finishes. A filament dryer removes this absorbed moisture, restoring the material to its optimal printing condition.

However, not all filament dryers are created equal. They differ in heating methods, temperature control, capacity, noise levels, sealing effectiveness, and price. This comparison dives into five popular choices – the Sunlu S1, eSUN eBox (often referring to the Lite version in budget comparisons), Sovol SH01, Sovol SH02, and Creality Space Pi Plus – examining them across key criteria to help you find the best fit for your needs and budget.

Detailed Dryer Comparison

Let's break down each model based on user feedback and specifications available as of April 10, 2025.

Sunlu S1 / S1 Plus

Noise

Generally considered one of the quieter options as the basic S1 model often lacks a fan. Operation is typically silent or very low noise.

Efficiency

Provides basic heating to dry filament. Temperature is adjustable, often stabilizing around 37-50°C depending on the specific model (S1 vs S1 Plus) and ambient conditions. It's effective for standard filaments like PLA and PETG but might be slow or insufficient for high-temperature materials requiring more heat.

Price

A budget-friendly choice, typically ranging from $35 to $50. Excellent entry-level price point.

Airtightness

Not primarily designed as a long-term airtight storage container. While it encloses the spool, it's not perfectly sealed and is best used actively for drying rather than passive storage without power, unless modified or used with ample desiccant.

Bang for the Buck

Offers good value for basic drying needs. If you primarily print PLA/PETG and need an affordable way to combat humidity occasionally, it's a solid choice. Less ideal for frequent, high-temp material drying or airtight storage.

eSUN eBox / eBox Lite

Noise

Can be moderately noisy. Some users report audible fan noise and distinct clicking sounds from the heating element's relay cycling on and off, which can be disruptive in quiet environments.

Efficiency

Offers decent drying performance, often capable of reaching 50-55°C. The eBox Lite is known for even heating. Some models include a built-in scale to weigh the filament, which is a useful feature. Performance is generally adequate for common filaments.

Price

Also positioned as a budget-friendly to mid-range option, often priced between $36 and $70, depending on the specific model (Lite vs. original) and retailer.

Airtightness

Generally considered to have better sealing than the basic Sunlu S1, offering moderate protection against dust and moisture ingress. Some comparisons suggest specific eSUN models (like the E2, not part of this direct comparison list) are more airtight than others.

Bang for the Buck

Provides good value, especially the Lite version, balancing cost with useful features like the potential built-in scale and decent drying. The noise might be a drawback for some users.

Sovol SH01

Noise

Frequently cited as being very noisy due to its fan. Some users find the noise level, occasionally described as high-pitched, to be a significant downside, sometimes requiring fan replacement or modifications.

Efficiency

Capable of holding and drying two 1kg spools simultaneously. Uses a basic heating element (often cited as 48W) and can reach temperatures suitable for common filaments (around 40-50°C, though some sources mention up to 70°C - verification needed per specific model revision). Temperature control is considered somewhat basic compared to newer models.

Price

Positioned as an affordable dual-spool dryer, typically ranging from $50 to $60, sometimes even lower during sales.

Airtightness

Features silicone seals around the lid and filament exit ports, aiming for better airtightness than basic boxes. However, user reports vary, with some noting it's not perfectly sealed for long-term unpowered storage.

Bang for the Buck

Offers excellent value if you need to dry two spools at once on a budget and can tolerate the noise. Its value proposition is strong based on capacity and price, but weakened by the noise and basic controls.

Sovol SH02

Noise

Can be noisy, particularly during the initial heat-up phase due to the fan. However, many users report it becomes significantly quieter once the target temperature is reached. While still audible, it's often considered an improvement over the SH01 or at least less consistently loud.

Efficiency

A significant upgrade from the SH01. Features a more powerful 150W PTC (Positive Temperature Coefficient) heater, enabling much faster heating (reaching 50°C in ~7 mins, 70°C in ~25 mins). Offers a wider temperature range (40-70°C) and better temperature control, often with presets for different filament types via a touch screen. Retains the two-spool capacity.

Price

More expensive than the SH01, typically ranging from $70 to $100. This reflects its upgraded heating system and controls.

Airtightness

Features improved sealing compared to the SH01, often described as having triple rings, silicone lid seals, and silicone plugs for the filament ports. While likely better sealed than its predecessor, user opinions still vary on whether it achieves true long-term airtight storage without power and desiccant.

Bang for the Buck

Considered to offer very good value. The higher price is justified by the significantly faster heating, higher temperature capability (crucial for Nylon, PC, etc.), better user interface, and improved (though perhaps not perfect) sealing. A strong contender for heavy users or those working with engineering-grade filaments.

Creality Space Pi Plus

Noise

Reports are mixed but lean towards it being noisy. Some users find the fan noise noticeable or even disruptive, potentially similar in level to the Sovol models. One source quotes 42 dB, which is moderately quiet, but user reviews often mention noticeable noise.

Efficiency

Utilizes dual PTC heating elements for efficient and potentially more even heat distribution, similar to the Sovol SH02. Capable of reaching temperatures suitable for a wide range of filaments (up to 65°C or 70°C depending on source). Features adjustable temperature and timer settings, often via a touchscreen interface. Also includes compartments for adding desiccant packs.

Price

Positioned in the mid-to-high range, typically costing between $90 and $130.

Airtightness

Features a well-fitting lid without obvious holes found on some simpler dryers. However, it reportedly lacks a dedicated gasket or seal like the Sovol models. While the design might limit passive air exchange, it's likely not truly airtight for long-term storage without relying on the internal desiccant.

Bang for the Buck

Offers excellent value for users seeking high performance. Its efficient PTC heating, capacity for two spools (or one large one), user-friendly interface, and desiccant integration make it a powerful tool, especially for moisture-sensitive filaments. The price is higher, but justified by the features and performance.

What's Needed to Compare Filament Dryers? Key Factors

When evaluating filament dryers, beyond the core criteria we've discussed, consider these factors:

• Temperature Range & Accuracy: Can it reach the necessary temperature for your specific filaments (e.g., PLA ~50°C, PETG ~65°C, Nylon/PC ~70°C+)? How accurately does it maintain the set temperature? PTC heaters generally offer faster heating and better stability.
• Heating Method & Circulation: Does it use a basic heating element or a more advanced PTC system? Is there a fan for air circulation to ensure even drying, or does it rely on passive convection? Fan-assisted models are often faster but noisier.
• Spool Capacity & Size Compatibility: How many spools can it hold (typically 1 or 2)? Can it accommodate different spool widths and diameters, including 0.5kg, 1kg, or potentially larger spools?
• Humidity Control & Monitoring: Does it have a built-in hygrometer to display the internal humidity level? Does it have vents for moisture to escape, or does it rely on internal desiccant?
• User Interface & Features: How easy is it to set the temperature and timer? Does it have presets for common filaments? Does it offer features like a filament scale (eSUN eBox) or desiccant compartments (Creality Space Pi Plus)?
• Build Quality & Materials: Does the unit feel sturdy? Are the materials heat-resistant and durable?
• Power Consumption: While drying, how much electricity does it use? More powerful heaters (like the 150W PTC in the SH02) consume more power but heat up much faster.

Comparative Analysis Radar Chart

This radar chart provides a visual comparison of the five filament dryers based on synthesized ratings across key attributes. Higher scores generally indicate better performance or value in that category (except for Noise, where a lower score is better, represented here as 'Quietness' where higher is better).

Feature Comparison Table

Here's a table summarizing the key characteristics and typical specifications of each filament dryer.

Visualizing Dryer Features: A Mindmap Overview

This mindmap illustrates the core characteristics and differentiating features of the filament dryers discussed, providing a quick visual reference.

Video Review Spotlight: Multi-Dryer Comparison

Watching comparative reviews can offer valuable insights into the real-world performance and user experience of these devices. This video tests multiple dryers, including models from eSUN, Sunlu, Sovol, and Creality, providing direct comparisons of their drying effectiveness and potentially touching upon noise and usability.

In this test, the reviewer often uses standardized methods (like drying a wet sponge or filament samples) and measures humidity changes over time to quantify performance. Pay attention to the setup, the measurement tools used, and the conclusions drawn about which dryers perform best under the test conditions. This can help contextualize the feature comparisons discussed earlier.

Gallery: Filament Dryers and Storage Solutions

Beyond dedicated electronic dryers, makers often use or build semi-passive "dry boxes" using airtight containers and desiccants. Active dryers like the ones compared offer controlled heating for faster moisture removal, while dry boxes excel at long-term storage. Here are some examples related to filament drying and storage:

Example of a commercial filament dryer (Sovol SH01) with active heating.

Example of a DIY dry box using an airtight container and desiccant for passive storage.

Another commercial filament dryer example, highlighting common features like viewing windows and digital displays.

Understanding the difference between active drying (using heat) and passive storage (using desiccants in a sealed environment) is key. Active dryers restore wet filament quickly, while dry boxes maintain dryness over long periods. Some users employ both: drying filament in an active dryer, then moving it to a passive dry box for storage.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

References

• Sovol Filament Dryer Storage Box SH02 Customer Reviews - Amazon
• Creality Space Pi Filament Dryer Plus Review & Specs - SyntaxGlow
• Official Creality Space Pi Filament Dryer Product Page - Amazon
• Best Filament Dryers 2025 and DIY Solutions - 3DWithUs
• Best Filament Dryers for 3D Printing - Kingroon
• 6 filament dryer test - which one dries better? eBox, eBox Lite... - My Tech Fun (YouTube)
• 6 filament dryer noise test - How loud are these drying boxes... - My Tech Fun (YouTube)

Recommended

How do DIY filament dry boxes compare to commercial heated dryers?

What are the specific drying temperatures and times needed for PLA, PETG, Nylon, and TPU?

Can I effectively use a food dehydrator to dry my 3D printing filament?

What are the best long-term storage methods to keep filament dry after opening?