Ithy Logo

Passing HTTP ACME Challenge with Cloudflare Proxy

A Comprehensive Guide to Successfully Verifying Domain Ownership

cloudflare acme challenge

Key Takeaways

  • Use Cloudflare Page Rules to Bypass Caching and Security for Challenge Paths
  • Prefer DNS-01 Challenge for Automation and Avoiding HTTP Redirection Issues
  • Ensure Proper Server Configuration to Serve Challenge Files Correctly

Understanding the HTTP ACME Challenge

What is the HTTP-01 ACME Challenge?

The HTTP-01 ACME (Automated Certificate Management Environment) challenge is a method used by Certificate Authorities (CAs) like Let's Encrypt to verify that a requester has control over a domain before issuing an SSL/TLS certificate. This process involves placing a specific file with a unique token at a designated URL on the domain. The CA then attempts to access this file over HTTP to confirm domain ownership.

Why Cloudflare Proxy Interferes with the Challenge

Cloudflare acts as a reverse proxy, routing traffic through its servers to provide benefits such as DDoS protection, caching, and SSL termination. While these features enhance security and performance, they can interfere with the HTTP-01 ACME challenge. Specifically, Cloudflare's proxy may block or redirect the ACME validation requests, preventing the CA from accessing the necessary challenge files directly on the origin server. This interference can lead to failed certificate issuance or renewal attempts.


Step-by-Step Guide to Passing the Challenge

1. Configuring Cloudflare Page Rules

To allow ACME validation requests to reach your origin server bypassing Cloudflare's proxy, you need to set up specific Page Rules. These rules ensure that requests to the ACME challenge path are not cached or subjected to Cloudflare's security measures.

  1. Access Cloudflare Dashboard: Log in to your Cloudflare account and navigate to the dashboard of the domain you wish to configure.
  2. Navigate to Page Rules: In the sidebar, click on "Page Rules" to access the Page Rules section.
  3. Create a New Rule: Click on "Create Page Rule" and enter the URL pattern for the ACME challenge. Typically, this is `*yourdomain.com/.well-known/acme-challenge/*`.
  4. Set the Rule Actions:
    • Cache Level: Bypass – Prevents Cloudflare from caching the challenge files.
    • Disable Security: Turns off security features for the challenge path, ensuring uninterrupted access.
    • Disable Performance Features: Ensures that performance optimizations do not interfere with the challenge.
  5. Save and Deploy: Save the rule and ensure it is active. This configuration directs ACME challenge requests straight to your origin server.

2. Setting Up Firewall Rules

In addition to Page Rules, configuring Firewall Rules can further ensure that ACME challenge requests are allowed through to your server without obstruction.

  1. Access Firewall Settings: Within the Cloudflare dashboard, navigate to the "Firewall" section.
  2. Create a New Firewall Rule: Set up a rule that specifically allows HTTP requests to the `/.well-known/acme-challenge/` path.
  3. Define the Action: Choose actions like "Allow" or "Skip" for requests matching the challenge path, ensuring they are not blocked or challenged by Cloudflare's security layers.
  4. Apply and Save: Activate the rule to ensure it takes effect immediately, facilitating successful ACME validations.

3. Server-Side Configuration

Proper configuration of your origin server is crucial to serve the ACME challenge files correctly.

  1. Create the Challenge Directory: Ensure that the `.well-known/acme-challenge/` directory exists within your web server's root directory.
  2. Set Correct Permissions: Verify that the server has appropriate permissions to read and serve files from the challenge directory.
  3. Configure Server to Serve Challenge Files: Adjust your web server's configuration (e.g., Nginx, Apache) to allow access to the challenge directory without redirections or additional security measures.
  4. Disable HTTPS Redirects for Challenge Path: If your server enforces HTTPS redirects globally, ensure that requests to the challenge path are exempted to allow HTTP access as required by the ACME challenge.
  5. Test Accessibility: Manually place a test file in the challenge directory and attempt to access it via HTTP to confirm that it is publicly accessible.

4. Testing the Setup

After configuring Cloudflare and your server, it's essential to test the setup to ensure the ACME challenge can be successfully completed.

  1. Trigger a Manual Certificate Renewal: Use your ACME client (e.g., Certbot) to initiate a certificate renewal or issuance process.
  2. Monitor Challenge Requests: Observe the ACME client's output to see if the challenge requests are reaching your server and being served correctly.
  3. Use Diagnostic Tools: Utilize tools like `curl` to attempt accessing the challenge URL directly from external sources to verify accessibility.
  4. Review Logs: Check your web server and Cloudflare logs for any errors or blocked requests related to the ACME challenge.
  5. Iterate if Necessary: If the challenge fails, revisit the previous steps to identify and rectify any misconfigurations.

Alternative Methods

Using DNS-01 Challenge

When the HTTP-01 challenge proves too complex or unreliable due to proxy interference, the DNS-01 challenge serves as a robust alternative. This method involves creating specific DNS TXT records to prove domain ownership.

  1. Select a Compatible ACME Client: Ensure your ACME client (e.g., Certbot, acme.sh) supports the DNS-01 challenge and can integrate with Cloudflare's API.
  2. Obtain Cloudflare API Credentials: Generate an API token in Cloudflare with permissions to manage DNS records for your domain. Store this token securely on your server.
  3. Configure the ACME Client: Set up your ACME client to use the Cloudflare API for automatically adding and removing the required TXT records during the certificate issuance and renewal processes.
  4. Initiate the DNS-01 Challenge: Run the ACME client to create the necessary TXT records in your DNS settings, allowing the CA to verify domain ownership.
  5. Automate Renewals: Configure scheduled tasks to automate the DNS-01 challenge process, ensuring seamless certificate renewals without manual intervention.

Dedicated Subdomains for Validation

Another strategy involves setting up dedicated subdomains exclusively for ACME challenge validations. By isolating the challenge process, you can maintain your main domain's security and performance configurations without interference.

  1. Create a Subdomain: Set up a subdomain (e.g., `acme.yourdomain.com`) designated solely for serving ACME challenge files.
  2. Configure DNS Settings: In Cloudflare DNS settings, configure the subdomain to be DNS-only (gray cloud icon) to bypass Cloudflare's proxy.
  3. Adjust Server Configuration: Ensure that your server serves the ACME challenge files correctly on the dedicated subdomain.
  4. Update ACME Client Settings: Point your ACME client to use the dedicated subdomain for placing and serving challenge files.
  5. Maintain Consistency: Regularly verify that the subdomain remains exclusively used for validation to prevent conflicts or security issues.

Cloudflare Origin Certificates

Cloudflare offers Origin Certificates, which are SSL certificates issued by Cloudflare to secure the connection between the origin server and Cloudflare. While these certificates do not replace public CA certificates like Let's Encrypt, they provide an alternative for securing proxied domains.

  1. Generate an Origin Certificate: In the Cloudflare dashboard, navigate to the SSL/TLS section and generate an Origin Certificate for your domain.
  2. Install the Certificate on Your Server: Configure your web server to use the generated Origin Certificate, ensuring encrypted traffic between Cloudflare and your origin.
  3. Adjust SSL Settings: Set Cloudflare's SSL mode to "Full" or "Full (Strict)" to utilize the Origin Certificate effectively.
  4. Benefit from Simplified Configuration: By using Origin Certificates, you can avoid complexities associated with public ACME challenges while maintaining secure connections.

Common Issues and Troubleshooting

Caching Problems

Cloudflare's caching mechanisms can sometimes store outdated or incorrect responses for the ACME challenge paths. To mitigate this:

  • Use Cache Bypass Rules: Implement Page Rules to bypass caching for `/.well-known/acme-challenge/*` paths.
  • Clear Cache Manually: After setting up the Page Rules, purge the cache for the challenge directories to ensure fresh content is served.

HTTPS Redirection Conflicts

If your server enforces HTTPS globally, it might redirect ACME HTTP challenge requests from HTTP to HTTPS, causing validation failures.

  • Exempt Challenge Paths: Configure your server to exclude `/.well-known/acme-challenge/` from HTTPS redirections.
  • Adjust Cloudflare Page Rules: Ensure that Page Rules for the challenge paths disable automatic HTTPS rewrites.

Permission Issues

Incorrect file permissions can prevent the server from serving ACME challenge files correctly.

  • Set Appropriate Permissions: Ensure that the `/.well-known/acme-challenge/` directory and its files are readable by the web server.
  • Verify Ownership: Confirm that the server process owns the challenge directory and files to avoid access restrictions.

Firewall Restrictions

Firewalls may inadvertently block ACME validation requests, hindering the challenge process.

  • Whitelist CA IPs: If possible, allow incoming connections from known Certificate Authority IP addresses.
  • Review Firewall Logs: Check logs to identify and unblock any requests related to ACME challenges.
  • Adjust Firewall Rules: Modify rules to permit HTTP access specifically to `/.well-known/acme-challenge/*` paths.

Best Practices

Automating Certificate Renewal

To ensure uninterrupted SSL/TLS coverage, automate the certificate renewal process.

  1. Use ACME Clients with Automation Support: Tools like Certbot can be scheduled via cron jobs or systemd timers to handle renewals automatically.
  2. Integrate with Cloudflare API: For DNS-01 challenges, configure your ACME client to interact with Cloudflare's API, allowing automated DNS record updates.
  3. Monitor Renewal Status: Implement monitoring to alert you in case of renewal failures, ensuring prompt resolution.

Securing API Tokens

When using DNS challenges with Cloudflare's API, it's crucial to secure your API tokens to prevent unauthorized access.

  • Use Least Privilege Principles: Grant only the necessary permissions required for the ACME client to function.
  • Store Tokens Securely: Keep API tokens in secure locations, such as environment variables or protected configuration files.
  • Rotate Tokens Regularly: Periodically update your API tokens to minimize security risks.

Maintaining Server Configuration

Consistent server configurations ensure that ACME challenges are served correctly.

  • Regularly Update Server Software: Keep your web server and associated software up-to-date to benefit from the latest security and performance improvements.
  • Document Configuration Changes: Maintain clear documentation of any changes made to server configurations related to ACME challenges.
  • Perform Routine Audits: Periodically review server settings to ensure that challenge paths remain accessible and correctly configured.

Implementation Example

Using Certbot with Cloudflare

Certbot is a popular ACME client that can automate the process of obtaining and renewing SSL/TLS certificates. Here's how to configure Certbot to work with Cloudflare for DNS-01 challenges:


# Install Certbot and Cloudflare DNS plugin
sudo apt-get update
sudo apt-get install certbot python3-certbot-dns-cloudflare

# Create a credentials file for Cloudflare
sudo nano /etc/letsencrypt/cloudflare.ini

# Add the following lines to cloudflare.ini
dns_cloudflare_api_token = YOUR_CLOUDFLARE_API_TOKEN

# Secure the credentials file
sudo chmod 600 /etc/letsencrypt/cloudflare.ini

# Obtain a certificate using DNS-01 challenge
sudo certbot certonly \\
  --dns-cloudflare \\
  --dns-cloudflare-credentials /etc/letsencrypt/cloudflare.ini \\
  -d yourdomain.com \\
  -d *.yourdomain.com
    

Creating a Cloudflare Page Rule

Below is an example of a Cloudflare Page Rule configuration to bypass cache and disable security for ACME challenge paths:


URL: *yourdomain.com/.well-known/acme-challenge/*
Settings:
  - Cache Level: Bypass
  - Disable Security: On
  - Disable Performance: On
    

Configuration Summary

Step Description Action Required
1 Configure Cloudflare Page Rules Set rules to bypass cache and disable security for ACME challenge paths.
2 Set Up API Credentials Create and secure API tokens for DNS-01 challenge automation.
3 Install and Configure ACME Client Install Certbot with Cloudflare plugin and configure credentials.
4 Initiate Certificate Request Run Certbot to obtain and install the SSL/TLS certificate.
5 Automate Renewal Set up cron jobs or systemd timers for automatic certificate renewal.

Conclusion

Successfully passing the HTTP ACME challenge while using Cloudflare's proxy services requires careful configuration both within Cloudflare and on your origin server. By implementing specific Page Rules to bypass caching and security for challenge paths, you ensure that ACME validation requests reach your server without interference. Alternatively, leveraging the DNS-01 challenge provides a robust and automated method for certificate issuance and renewal, especially when integrated with Cloudflare's API. Regardless of the chosen method, maintaining proper server configurations and adhering to best security practices are paramount to ensuring seamless and secure SSL/TLS certificate management.

References


Last updated February 4, 2025
Search Again